The Best Seafood Restaurants in Toronto

No.1

Restaurant• King West

Rodney's Oyster House

“Don't miss their 'oyster garden' patio in warmer months for a secluded, maritime-inspired dining experience.”

— Very Toronto Editors

Established in 1987 by the late Rodney Clark, this King West institution is the spiritual home of the Toronto oyster scene. Originally a graphic designer from PEI who started by shipping oysters to friends, Clark built a legacy rooted in Maritime hospitality and an uncompromising dedication to fresh seafood. The atmosphere is unapologetically nautical, featuring warm wood, mounted fish, and a collection of quirky mementos that give the space a lived-in, rowdy charm. It is the kind of place where the staff knows their product intimately and the vibe balances between a casual neighbourhood hangout and a bustling, high-energy destination for seafood lovers. Whether you are sitting at the bar or in the dining room, the focus remains squarely on the quality of the catch. For a first-timer, the strategy is simple: order a dozen oysters immediately, even before your first drink. The daily selection changes based on what is freshest from the Atlantic and Pacific coasts, and the shuckers are always happy to guide your choices. Beyond the raw bar, the New England clam chowder is a standout, and the Atlantic lobster roll is consistently excellent. Expect a mid-to-high price range, which is justified by the quality of the imports. Reservations are highly recommended for table seating, though the oyster bar is kept open for walk-ins if you prefer a more spontaneous, social experience. Keep an eye out for their weekday 'Low Tide' happy hour for some of the best value in the city.

Read Full Review

No.2

Restaurant• Scarborough

Fishman Lobster Clubhouse Restaurant

“Prepare for an epic feast and bring a crowd to tackle their legendary 'Lobster Mountain.'”

— Very Toronto Editors

Fishman Lobster Clubhouse has become a Scarborough institution, largely thanks to its unapologetic commitment to excess. Tucked away in a nondescript plaza on Finch Avenue, this isn't a place for an intimate, quiet dinner; it is a loud, bustling, and high-energy environment designed for large groups and celebrations. The restaurant is legendary for its Hong Kong-style seafood, specifically the massive, gravity-defying towers of lobster and king crab that arrive at tables with dramatic flair. The decor is functional and utilitarian, keeping the focus entirely on the sheer scale of the food being served. It is the kind of place where the kitchen staff treats crustaceans like architectural materials, stacking them high in a way that feels both absurd and impressive, making it a quintessential spot for a boisterous family gathering or a birthday dinner where you want to make a statement. For a first-timer, the strategy is simple: bring a crowd and order the set menu featuring their signature deep-fried lobster or king crab. The crustacean is typically prepared with a generous coating of garlic, chili, and scallions, providing a punchy, savory crunch that defines their house style. Prices are definitely on the higher end, reflecting the market cost of these premium ingredients, so come prepared to split the bill. Reservations are essential, especially on weekends, as the dining room fills up rapidly with large parties. It is a cash-only establishment, a quirk that catches many off guard, so visit an ATM before you arrive. While the service can be frantic during peak hours, the experience of tackling a mountain of seafood with friends is unmatched in the city.

Read Full Review

No.3

Restaurant• West Queen West

Prime Seafood Palace

“The interior, designed as a 'light-filled wood cathedral,' is as impressive as the meticulously prepared seafood and dry-aged steaks.”

— Very Toronto Editors

Prime Seafood Palace is Matty Matheson’s ambitious, high-end departure from his more casual roots, and it feels every bit the 'wooden cathedral' he envisioned. Designed by Omar Gandhi, the space is an architectural marvel—an immersive, barrel-vaulted dining room entirely clad in white maple that feels like a serene, upscale mountain retreat hidden right in the middle of the bustling West Queen West strip. Despite the celebrity chef pedigree, the atmosphere is surprisingly refined and quiet, with a focus on Scandinavian hygge and Japanese minimalism. It’s a place where the design is as much a part of the experience as the meal, offering a sophisticated, intimate escape from the city’s usual noise. For a first-timer, the menu is a study in restraint, balancing top-tier Atlantic seafood with serious, grill-fired proteins. You absolutely must order the Palace potatoes—crispy, pave-style wedges that are essentially the best hash browns you’ll ever eat—and the Sicilian crudo is a perfect, fresh start. The bone-in dry-aged striploin is the main event for meat lovers, but don't overlook the seasonal vegetable preparations, which are treated with the same reverence as the seafood. Expect a high price point, so save this for a special occasion. Reservations are essential and highly competitive, so book well in advance. If you can't snag a table, try your luck at the bar, where the service is just as attentive and the vibe is equally polished.

Read Full Review

No.4

Restaurant• Financial District

The Chase Fish and Oyster

“Indulge in their seafood towers and don't miss the opportunity to try their expertly crafted cocktails.”

— Very Toronto Editors

Tucked into the historic Dineen building, The Chase Fish and Oyster brings a polished, Hamptons-inspired aesthetic to the heart of the Financial District. It is the more relaxed, main-floor sibling to the rooftop restaurant above, yet it maintains a sophisticated edge that fits perfectly with the surrounding corporate crowd. The space is bright and breezy, featuring nautical accents like boat sails tethered to the rafters and crisp, preppy decor. It is a reliable spot for a business lunch or a post-work cocktail, offering a lively, upscale atmosphere that feels both professional and welcoming without being overly stuffy. For a first-timer, the raw bar is non-negotiable; the oyster selection is consistently fresh and well-curated. If you are looking for something more substantial, the lobster roll is a classic choice, and the menu often features refined takes on seafood staples like chowder and po' boys. While it leans heavily into pescatarian fare, they do offer solid meat options if you are dining with a group of mixed preferences. Expect to spend in the higher range, typical for this neighbourhood. Reservations are highly recommended, especially during the busy weekday lunch rush or Thursday and Friday evenings when the bar area fills up quickly.

Read Full Review