Old Avenue Restaurant

What is Old Avenue Restaurant? Perched along an active stretch of Avenue Road in Midtown, Old Avenue Restaurant doubles as a bakery and dining room rooted in Azerbaijani and Georgian home-style cooking. The interior channels an evocative, retro warmth reminiscent of a mid-century family home, filled with antique relics, retro 3D scenery, and comfortable black leather booths that encourage lingering over slow meals.

Old Avenue Restaurant Menu & What to Order The kitchen excels at wood-fired breads, stuffed pastries, and deeply comforting meats cooked over open fire or in clay vessels. Kick things off with thin griddled kutab stuffed with spiced greens or sweetened pumpkin, alongside a boat-shaped cheese khachapuri finished with a runny yolk. For mains, the communal saj platters loaded with spiced meats and blistered vegetables steal the show, though the dainty dushbere dumplings swimming in rich lamb broth and the ceremonial Shah Plov are equally compelling. Finish with strong tea and their layered, house-baked Azerbaijani baklava, which sets a high benchmark for the city.

Know Before You Go Reservations are strongly recommended for weekend dinners and large parties, as table turnover is relaxed and groups tend to settle in for feast-style dining. Drivers can rely on Green P street parking along Avenue Road, or catch the 61 Avenue Rd bus running north from Lawrence or Eglinton stations. Note the split-service hours during the week, with doors closing briefly mid-afternoon Monday through Thursday before reopening for dinner.