The Fourth Man in the Fire

What is The Fourth Man in the Fire? Occupying the former Campagnolo address at 832 Dundas Street West, The Fourth Man in the Fire is Shant Mardirosian’s (the original mind behind The Burger’s Priest) tribute to classic, unpretentious American-style pizza parlours. The Trinity-Bellwoods dining room swaps fine-dining formality for olive-green walls lined with framed vintage headshots, low pendant lighting, and casual wooden tables. It operates as a no-nonsense, neighbourhood red-sauce sanctuary complete with an attached daytime counter for fresh doughnuts and cinnamon buns.

The Fourth Man in the Fire Menu & What to Order The kitchen specializes in foldable 18-inch NYC-style pies, thick Sicilian-style Brooklyn squares, and massive deep-fried ponzos. The cupping Pepperoni and the Sausage, Onion & Hot Honey pizzas are essential orders, built on sturdy, blistered crusts that support generous layers of cheese and tangy tomato sauce. Round out the table with an aggressively seasoned, cheese-dusted Caesar salad, a plate of Looney Stix with marinara, or the chicken parmesan alla vodka, and grab a Harry and Heels California-style donut or monster cinnamon bun on your way out.

Know Before You Go Seating is handled on a walk-in basis; turnover moves steadily, but prime Friday and Saturday evening slots can yield a brief wait. The 505 Dundas streetcar drops off steps away at Euclid Avenue, making transit easier than hunting for scarce street parking along Dundas West. Dine-in visitors can take advantage of exceptionally fair pricing on house draft beers and carafes of table wine.