Prince Street Pizza Canada

What is Prince Street Pizza Canada? Prince Street Pizza Canada is the northern flagship of New York City's iconic Nolita slice shop, located at 472 Front Street West inside the bustling complex of The Well in Wellington Place. Bringing Manhattan's celebrated crispy square pies to Downtown Toronto, the vibrant eatery is instantly recognizable by its signature neon signage, black-and-white tiled walls, and hot display warmers packed with golden focaccia-style Sicilian squares. It provides a bustling destination for downtown office workers, food hall explorers, and late-night pizza devotees seeking authentic NYC sourdough slices.

Prince Street Pizza Canada Menu & What to Order The legendary Spicy Spring™ Sicilian Square is the mandatory first order—a thick, airy, olive oil-crisped dough base layered with spicy fra diavolo marinara, melted fresh mozzarella, and a mountain of thick-cut pepperoni slices that crisp into chalice-like grease cups. Another hit is the Spicy Vodka Square, coated in velvety pink vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella. If you love sweet heat, order The Naughty Pie, which combines spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, dollops of ricotta cheese, and a generous drizzle of hot honey. Round Neapolitan-style pies like The Original Prince and Mercer Margherita provide thinner crispy alternatives, alongside golden Truffle Mozzarella Arancini.

Know Before You Go Prince Street Pizza operates seven days a week from 11:00 AM until 11:00 PM from Sunday to Wednesday, extending to midnight Thursday through Saturday. Slices are served hot and ready from the counter, with whole 12-inch and 18-inch pies baked to order. Indoor seating is shared within The Well's modern dining concourse. St. Andrew subway station is a short walk away, or take the 504 King streetcar to Spadina Avenue.