Peggy's Caribbean Cuisine

What is Peggy's Caribbean Cuisine? Peggy's Caribbean Cuisine is a no-frills, family-operated takeout counter situated at 402 Old Kingston Road in Scarborough's historic Highland Creek neighbourhood. Tucked into an unassuming commercial strip near the University of Toronto Scarborough campus, Peggy's has earned fierce neighbourhood loyalty through slow-cooked homestyle Jamaican classics, generous cafeteria-style portions, and welcoming warmth. The small counter specializes in deeply seasoned stews and grilled meats simmered for hours until fall-apart tender, serving local tradespeople, university students, and East End families.

Peggy's Caribbean Cuisine Menu & What to Order The crown jewel of Peggy's kitchen is the Braised Oxtail, slow-simmered in rich browning, allspice, thyme, and broad butter beans until the meat slides cleanly off the bone into a thick, velvety gravy. The Jerk Chicken delivers authentic Scotch bonnet heat paired with smoky char and aromatic pimento notes, accompanied by a side of spicy house barbecue sauce. Another standout is the Curry Goat, featuring lean cuts marinated in Jamaican yellow curry and Scotch bonnet peppers until meltingly soft. Every platter includes a massive mound of fragrant rice and peas infused with coconut milk, steamed cabbage, and sweet fried plantains. Grab a flaky golden Jamaican beef patty for the walk home.

Know Before You Go Peggy's is primarily a takeout joint with limited high-top counter seating. Peak lunch and dinner rushes move quickly, but popular items like oxtail frequently sell out by late afternoon, so arrive early. The restaurant operates Monday through Thursday from 12:00 PM to 7:00 PM, and Friday through Saturday until 8:00 PM; closed on Sundays. Surface plaza parking is free and straightforward right out front.