City Pizza

What is City Pizza? Situated in a busy commercial strip along Markham Road in Morningside Heights, City Pizza operates as a fast-paced neighbourhood counter turning out classic comfort food alongside bold South Asian fusion pies. The space is decidedly casual and no-frills, designed around a quick-service pickup counter and minimal seating rather than lingering dining room service.

City Pizza Menu & What to Order While standard pepperoni and Hawaiian pies are on offer, the primary draw here is the extensive roster of desi-style creations. Standouts include the Butter Chicken Pizza layered with aromatic makhani-spiced poultry and the deeply seasoned Mutton Keema Pizza, balanced by vegetarian heavyweights like the Shahi Paneer Pizza. Round out the order with the halal oven-baked desi-style chicken wings, glazed in punchy spices that cut right through the melted mozzarella.

Know Before You Go This is strictly a walk-in counter and takeout hub, so call ahead or order online to bypass brief line-ups. Free plaza parking makes curb pickup effortless, though ticket times stretch on Friday and Saturday evenings when the kitchen runs until nearly midnight.