Caffe Cinquecento

What is Caffe Cinquecento? Anchored inside the Columbus Centre at 901 Lawrence Avenue West, Caffe Cinquecento operated as a community Italian bar and eatery bridging morning espresso rituals with casual midday dining. The setting prioritized ease and utility, pairing simple counter service and indoor tables with an inviting outdoor patio and a curated 'mercato' shelf of imported pantry staples.

Caffe Cinquecento Menu & What to Order The kitchen centered on straightforward, everyday Italian comfort, turning out crisp-crusted pizzas alongside quick lunch wraps and bowls. The Tartufo Pizza balanced earthy aroma with melted mozzarella, while the classic Margherita and anchovy-laced Napoletana delivered reliable, traditional profiles. Golden, crisp arancini offered an ideal savoury bite ahead of a fresh ricotta-filled cannoli and a sharp pull of espresso.

Know Before You Go Please note that Caffe Cinquecento has permanently ceased operations at this Lawrence West address, with the space transitioning to new quick-service concept Pantry. Historically, the venue was entirely walk-in and counter-driven, supported by ample on-site surface parking across the Villa Charities complex.