Bagel Plus

What is Bagel Plus? Anchoring Sheppard Avenue West in Bathurst Manor since 1979, Bagel Plus operates as an enduring Jewish dairy restaurant and old-school bakery. The dining room is unpretentious and buzzing with neighbourhood regulars, offering comfortable booth and table seating alongside a high-turnover takeout counter packed with fresh breads. It is an unfussy North York institution built around generational loyalty and traditional comfort.

Bagel Plus Menu & What to Order The hand-rolled, additive-free bagels serve as the cornerstone here, dense with a firm chew and best paired with cream cheese and silky smoked salmon. For hot mains, the golden-fried cheese blintzes with sour cream are deeply satisfying, as is the restorative matzo ball soup loaded with tender dumplings and fragrant dill. Before leaving, hit the bakery counter for a loaf of freshly baked caraway rye, a slice of braided babka, or their towering lemon meringue pie.

Know Before You Go The restaurant operates entirely on a walk-in basis, meaning weekend breakfast and midday rushes can bring brief waits for dining room tables. Street and plaza parking are readily accessible along Sheppard, and transit riders can easily hop on the 84 Sheppard West bus. Doors are open daily from 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. for full-service meals or quick takeout pastry runs.